There are a wide variety of theories
on how population growth will affect our future. Most population growth
arguments are polar opposites, believing growth will save the world through its
advances in technology or it will destroy the world through ecosystem
degradation and resource depletion. Homer-Dixon believes the latter and argues
that population growth plays a negative role by causing an increased demand for
resources and will lead to environmental scarcity and eventually conflict.
However he also recognizes the possibility of population growth causing a boost
in productivity, technological advances, and even environmental improvement.
Using the research that has been
done on population growth, a plan should be formulated to maximize the benefits
and minimize the consequences of population growth. Because growth seems to be
inevitable, there should be a plan to make sure it is done in the safest way possible
to avoid the potential harms. Creating a concept of smart population growth
would help to avoid many of the problems Homer-Dixon fears may occur in the
future. Smart population growth could be a term similar to sustainability with
a somewhat vague definition with the goal of achieving a promising future for
everyone. However smart population growth would also have specific goals tied
to the concept, to avoid the problems many predict population growth will cause
in the future. By following the goals of smart population growth, growth could
provide the benefits of advances in technology while avoiding problems such as
resource depletion.
One goal could be a commitment to
education throughout the world. Education aids in reducing early pregnancies
and encouraging adolescents to work hard towards achieving a promising career
path. Encouraging teenagers and especially females to put their career first
will aid in avoiding teen pregnancies and will most likely result in them
having fewer children as they get older. Additionally, education and access to
contraceptives should also be an important element of this step and will help
to avoid early pregnancies. This should be especially prevalent in developing
countries, to help keep their growth stabilized and not at an exponential rate.
By keeping growth at a slow and steady rate, there will be more time to find
ways to support higher numbers of people without depleting resources.
Exponential growth is much more dangerous as the population increases at a rate
that is difficult to keep up with.
Additionally, placing an emphasis
on education will ensure that technological advances will be created to help
support the growing population. Many people argue that as population continues
to grow, advances in technology will allow the world to support more and more
people. This has already been the case as the carrying capacity has increased over
the past few decades. There is even the possibility of environmental
improvements as technology improves. A focus on education will encourage kids
to continue their commitment to learning and researching in the future and will
hopefully lead to advances in technology to help support the population. Placing
an emphasis on education, especially in areas where it may be inadequate, will
help to improve the future of many. It could also aid in reducing gaps of
income inequality, as education helps provide a more promising future. This
helps to address Homer-Dixon’s concern that poorer groups will migrate to
vulnerable areas and will cause land degradation to these areas.
Another goal in smart growth could
be to work towards creating long lasting material goods. This goal is very
tricky to address, but it would be an important step towards avoiding
Homer-Dixon’s concerns of population growth causing increased resource
consumption. Perhaps one of the leading causes of high resource demand is the
fact that many goods are not long lasting. By encouraging manufacturers to
create long lasting goods and encouraging customers to purchase long lasting
goods, resource demand would go down. Additionally encouraging consumers to get
broken appliances repaired instead of replacing with new appliances would help
in lowering the resource demand.
Homer-Dixon raises many points
about how population growth could affect the future. However, unless very
strict population growth prevention policies are implemented, which is
extremely unlikely, it is a problem that will have to be dealt with. Population
growth does not have to only cause consequences to the world. By focusing on education and strategies to
lower resource demand, the problems of population growth can be avoided and the
potential benefits will become more likely.
As you know, China did the one child policy to help with population control. Do you think that is a feasible idea for other future population problems, or could you not see any other countries partaking in something like that. I agree with education though, it seems to reduce pregnancy a great deal!
ReplyDeleteI agree that education is an important tool. Unfortunately, it's not something with a straight line through implementation and goals being met. To my knowledge, there is no way of knowing for certain that population trends will change by a specific number or magnitude on education. Education is important in all aspects and should be further implemented. I'm curious if there are more discrete ways we can link our actions to controlling population growth to sustainable levels.
ReplyDeleteWhen attempting to reduce resource demand it is important to consider the role human values have in shaping consumption habits. For example, while in some households it is common to make use of a good like a computer until it is unusable, in some countries and families older models of a good are immediately discarded for the latest model. I think that if we want to reduce the demand for resources especially in developed nations we have to change this pattern of rapid and often unnecessary consumption.
ReplyDeleteI really liked your idea on emphasizing education and technological advancement to produce smart population. One consequence, I think, that people do not heavily discuss about in regards to technological advancement is the possible over-exploitation of resources/land. Therefore, as countries invest in education and human development to help them achieve "smart population." I think educating the population about how to utilize technological advancement effectively without resulting in exploitation of resources is also important.
ReplyDelete